Old Overholt, one of the oldest whiskey brands in America, has made waves with the release of its new 11-year-old cask strength rye whiskey. This latest offering, under Beam Suntory, continues the brand’s ongoing transformation, building on previous releases and catering to whiskey enthusiasts who appreciate bolder, more mature expressions. Bottled at 107.4 proof, the new Old Overholt Extra Aged Cask Strength 11-Year Rye is expected to capture attention with its refined taste and rich history.
A Legacy of Resilience and Evolution
Old Overholt is far from a newcomer to the whiskey world. Its roots trace back to the early 1800s when Abraham Overholt, a German immigrant, started distilling in West Overton, Pennsylvania. The brand has weathered many changes over the centuries, including different ownerships and evolving production techniques. In 1987, Jim Beam acquired Old Overholt, bringing the distilling operations to Kentucky, where it continues to produce high-quality rye whiskey.
Overholt’s historical significance is key to its lasting success. As the longest continually maintained whiskey brand in America, it has adapted through time, while still maintaining its commitment to quality. Beam Suntory has reinvigorated the brand over the past few years, improving its core expressions by increasing the proof and aging the whiskey longer. These strategic changes have helped Old Overholt not only retain its loyal following but also attract new whiskey drinkers looking for a mix of heritage and innovation.
The Latest Cask Strength Release: A Step Up in Age and Complexity
The new 11-year-old rye follows in the footsteps of previous cask strength releases from Old Overholt. Back in 2020, the brand released its first 11-year-old expression, bottled at 92.6 proof. It marked a turning point for the brand, which also introduced non-chill filtration and updated packaging to appeal to a modern audience. In 2023, the brand launched a 10-year cask strength rye bottled at a robust 121 proof. This latest 11-year cask strength whiskey builds upon that momentum, offering an older, more refined option for whiskey lovers.
What sets the 2024 release apart is not just the age but also the proof. At 107.4 proof, it is notably lower in alcohol than last year’s 121-proof 10-year release. This lower proof might appeal to drinkers who prefer a more balanced, approachable whiskey while still enjoying the intensity that cask strength offers. The barrels for this whiskey were aged in four different warehouses in Clermont, Kentucky, and selected from lower floors where temperatures are cooler. The result, according to Beam Suntory’s American Whiskey Ambassador Tim Heuisler, was a pleasant surprise. The team felt that the whiskey had matured beautifully, despite its lower proof, offering a unique taste profile that showcases the brand’s signature rye flavors.
Tasting Notes: A Complex and Full-Bodied Experience
The official tasting notes for Old Overholt Extra Aged Cask Strength 11-Year Rye highlight the whiskey’s rich complexity. On the nose, drinkers can expect bold aromas of vanilla with a subtle hint of tobacco spice, setting the stage for a robust sensory experience. The palate follows with flavors of allspice, sweet vanilla, caramel, and charred oak—elements that come together to create a well-rounded, full-bodied whiskey. The finish is described as lingering, with pleasant notes of rye, leaving a satisfying warmth after each sip.
This flavor profile aligns with the brand’s high-rye mashbill, though the exact breakdown of grains is kept under wraps. Rye whiskey fans will appreciate the spice-forward nature of this release, tempered by the sweetness of vanilla and caramel, making it a versatile option for both sipping neat and mixing in cocktails.
Affordability Meets Premium Quality
Old Overholt has long been known for producing quality rye whiskey at an affordable price. While the brand has released more premium expressions in recent years, it continues to offer value for whiskey lovers. The new 11-year cask strength rye is priced at $99.99, positioning it as a premium option within reach for many enthusiasts. The price reflects both the age and quality of the whiskey, making it a competitive choice in the ever-expanding market of high-end rye.
As a brand, Old Overholt has always maintained a strong presence in the bar community. Bartenders have long appreciated its versatility and reliability as a solid base for classic rye cocktails. With the introduction of higher-proof and older expressions, Old Overholt is now catering to the growing demand for more complex, premium whiskeys while still holding onto its roots as a go-to rye for everyday enjoyment.
A Testament to Old Overholt’s Future
The release of Old Overholt’s 11-Year Extra Aged Cask Strength Rye Whiskey signifies the brand’s commitment to pushing boundaries while staying true to its heritage. Beam Suntory’s dedication to improving the quality and range of offerings has revitalized Old Overholt, making it a serious contender in the premium rye whiskey category.
The strategic selection of barrels from various warehouses, the careful blending process, and the attention to proofing all demonstrate that Old Overholt isn’t just riding on its historical significance but is actively shaping its future. This new release may appeal to a wide range of whiskey drinkers, from those who appreciate a well-crafted cocktail to aficionados who savor every nuanced sip.
With nationwide distribution slated for this month, Old Overholt’s new 11-year-old cask strength rye is expected to be a hit among whiskey fans. Whether for its rich history, complex flavor profile, or balanced proof, this latest release is a testament to the brand’s enduring legacy and its exciting future in the world of American whiskey. Keep an eye out for this release at your local liquor store, as it is expected to sell out quickly.