For men across America who appreciate a good whiskey, High West Distillery’s 2025 release of The Prisoner’s Share is something to get excited about. This limited-edition blend of straight bourbon and rye whiskeys, finished in red wine barrels, brings a bold and unique flavor profile that stands out in the crowded world of American whiskey. With its rich complexity, smooth finish, and a price tag of $174.99, this whiskey is crafted for those who enjoy savoring every sip and sharing a bottle with friends over a good conversation.
High West, based in Utah, has built a reputation for pushing the boundaries of traditional whiskey-making, and The Prisoner’s Share is a prime example of their innovative approach. First introduced in 2022, this whiskey has quickly become a fan favorite for its creative use of red wine barrel finishing. The 2025 release, which hit shelves nationwide on June 1, 2025, takes this concept to new heights, blending the best of bourbon and rye with the deep, fruity influence of The Prisoner Red Blend wine barrels. The result is a whiskey that’s as much a treat for the senses as it is a testament to High West’s craftsmanship.
What sets The Prisoner’s Share apart is its unique aging process. The whiskey is a blend of straight bourbon and rye, with the mash bills carefully selected to create a balanced yet complex flavor. The blend includes five different mash bills, ranging from a high-corn bourbon (75% corn, 21% rye, 4% malted barley) to a high-rye whiskey (95% rye, 5% malted barley). High West also adds its own signature touch with an 80% rye, 20% malted rye whiskey. Some of these components come from MGP, a well-known distillery, while others are produced in-house by High West. The whiskeys are then finished in red wine barrels for anywhere from four to 12 years, allowing the oak and wine to impart rich, fruity, and spicy notes that elevate the final product.
When you pour a glass of The Prisoner’s Share 2025, the first thing you notice is the aroma. It’s a warm, inviting mix of pomegranate kernels, cranberry biscotti, and pecan brittle, with hints of orange zest and cinnamon bark adding a bright, spicy edge. There’s also a subtle note of light roast espresso and tanned leather, evoking the image of an old cedar closet. It’s the kind of scent that makes you want to linger over the glass, taking in every nuance before the first sip.
On the palate, this whiskey delivers a flavor explosion that’s both rich and approachable. You’ll taste tart Montmorency cherries and raspberry preserves spread over warm brioche toast, with deeper notes of cacao nibs and brown butter caramel adding a touch of sweetness. Roasted chestnuts and bergamot tea bring an earthy, citrusy balance, while the seasoned French oak from the wine barrels ties it all together with a smooth, woody backbone. The finish is where the rye shines through, leaving a lingering taste of black currant jam with just a hint of spice that keeps things lively without overpowering the other flavors.
Bottled at 102 proof (51% ABV), The Prisoner’s Share has enough strength to stand up to a splash of water or a single ice cube, but it’s smooth enough to enjoy neat. High West skips chill filtration, a process that can strip away some of the whiskey’s natural oils and flavors, opting instead for light particulate filtration to preserve the full depth of the taste. This choice ensures that every sip is packed with the complex flavors that make this whiskey so special.
At $174.99, The Prisoner’s Share isn’t an everyday bottle, but it’s priced right for a special occasion or a treat for whiskey enthusiasts. High West calls it one of their favorite limited-edition releases, and it’s easy to see why. It’s a sipping whiskey meant to be enjoyed slowly, whether you’re kicking back after a long day, hosting a poker night, or toasting a milestone with friends. The limited availability adds to its appeal—once it’s gone, it’s gone until the next release.
For guys who enjoy exploring new whiskeys, The Prisoner’s Share offers a chance to experience something different. It’s not just another bourbon or rye; it’s a bold experiment that combines the best of American whiskey with the sophisticated influence of red wine barrels. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just someone who likes a good drink, this whiskey is worth seeking out. Check with your local liquor store or online retailers to snag a bottle before it disappears from shelves.
