Supreme Court Takes Up a Law That Goes Back to 1868
The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case that asks a simple question with big consequences: how far can Congress reach into a person’s home? On October 19, 2026, the justices granted review in Department of Justice v. McNutt. The case centers on a federal rule that has been on the books since 1868, which bars the production of distilled spirits in a dwelling house. The ban also covers any shed, yard, or enclosure connected to a home.
The ruling could shape how courts view the limits of federal power over private, non-commercial activity that takes place inside a person’s own home. This article is informational only and looks at the legal questions, the two cases involved, and a public webinar planned for this week.
What the McNutt Case Is About
At the heart of McNutt is the location rule. The federal law does not simply tax spirits. It also says where they may not be made, and a home is on the list of banned places.
In April 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit looked at that rule and found that it goes too far. The court held that the ban exceeds Congress’s power under the Taxation Clause and the Necessary and Proper Clause. The federal government appealed, and the Supreme Court said it would take the case.
The justices will decide whether the location restriction is a necessary and proper means of carrying into execution Congress’s power to lay and collect taxes. In plain terms, the Court will ask whether banning an activity in a certain place is a fair way to help collect a tax, or whether it stretches the government’s power too far.
Why the Taxing Power Matters
The Constitution gives Congress the power to lay and collect taxes. It also lets Congress make laws that are “necessary and proper” to carry out its powers. The two ideas work together in this case.
The government’s side of the argument is that the location rule helps it collect taxes. The other side says a rule keeping an activity out of a home is not really about collecting money, and that it reaches into private life in a way the tax power was never meant to allow.
A decision in McNutt will clarify the outer limits of federal authority over private activity in the home. That is why the case is drawing attention well beyond the world of spirits. The same reasoning could come up in other fights over how far federal law can go when it touches what people do on their own property.
The Second Case: Ream v. U.S. Department of Treasury
McNutt is not the only case in play. A companion case, Ream v. U.S. Department of Treasury, was brought by The Buckeye Institute on behalf of John Ream. Ream lives in Ohio and wants to distill small amounts of spirits in his own home for personal use.
Ream’s case went through the Sixth Circuit, and the outcome there was different. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld the same federal ban. That put two appeals courts on opposite sides of the same question and created what lawyers call a circuit split. These splits are one of the main reasons the Supreme Court steps in.
Ream also raises questions under the Commerce Clause, which adds another layer to the dispute. The Supreme Court has chosen to hold the Ream petition while it waits on McNutt. So the result in the granted case will directly shape what happens next in the Ohio litigation and the wider constitutional issues it raises.
Free Webinar Set for Wednesday, November 18
For those who want to hear the issues explained by the lawyers involved, a webinar has been planned. It will take place on Wednesday, November 18, from 4:00 to 4:45 p.m. ET. The discussion will cover the main issues in McNutt, especially the limits on Congress’s taxing power and the Necessary and Proper Clause as they apply to private activity in the home. The speakers will also talk about what the decision could mean for the Ream case.
People who want to attend are asked to RSVP to Jennifer Ohman at Jen@advocacyink.com. She will then send the Zoom link.
Meet the Speakers
Robert Alt
Robert Alt is the president and chief executive officer of The Buckeye Institute, and he is one of the attorneys on the case. He also serves on the group’s Board of Directors. After taking the helm in 2012, he helped the organization grow quickly and founded its Economic Research Center and Legal Center. In 2026, the State Policy Network honored him with its Thomas A. Roe Award for Excellence in Leadership.
Alt is a scholar and attorney with a focus on constitutional law, legal policy, criminal justice, and national security. He often shares his views on podcasts, television, and radio. He has testified before Congress several times, including at the confirmation hearings for U.S. Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan.
His earlier work includes time with former U.S. Attorney General Edwin Meese III. He also spent five months in Iraq as an embedded war correspondent. He is an officer of The Philadelphia Society and of the Federalist Society’s Columbus Lawyers Chapter, and he once taught at Case Western Reserve University School of Law and Ashland University. Alt earned his law degree at The University of Chicago and went on to clerk for Judge Alice Batchelder on the Sixth Circuit. Outside the law, he is a high-altitude mountaineer who has summited the Seven Summits of the World, Mount Everest among them.
Andrew M. Grossman
Andrew M. Grossman is a senior legal fellow at The Buckeye Institute and the counsel of record on the McNutt case. He is also a partner in the Washington, D.C., office of BakerHostetler LLP, where he co-leads the appellate and major motions team.
Grossman has worked on many high-profile cases about federal authority, the separation of powers, and individual rights. He has drawn attention for his work before the Supreme Court, including First Amendment cases, well-known amicus briefs, and cases about class-action law and federal agency power.
He has also written widely on law and finance, bankruptcy law, administrative law, and the separation of powers. Members of Congress often turn to him for advice on complex legal questions, especially on the constitutional limits of federal power, and he has testified many times before the House and Senate Judiciary Committees. His commentary has run in The Wall Street Journal, USA Today, The Washington Post, and the Los Angeles Times.
Grossman is part of the leadership of the Federalist Society and is an adjunct scholar at the Cato Institute’s Robert A. Levy Center for Constitutional Studies. He once served as a fellow at the Heritage Foundation. He clerked for Judge Edith H. Jones on the Fifth Circuit, and he is a graduate of Dartmouth College, the University of Pennsylvania’s Fels Institute of Government, and George Mason University School of Law.
What Comes Next
With review granted, the Supreme Court will now take up briefs and arguments in McNutt. Whatever the justices decide, the ruling will say something about where Congress’s taxing power ends and where a person’s private life at home begins. The Ream case will stay on hold until then, and the outcome in McNutt will help decide how that case moves forward.
For anyone following the fight over federal power and personal liberty, the next few months should be worth watching.