Speyside vs. Islay vs. Highland: Which Scotch Region Is Right for You

Speyside vs. Islay vs. Highland: Which Scotch Region Is Right for You

Scotland's whisky landscape is one of the most geographically diverse in the spirits world, where the region a whisky comes from can tell you almost as much about what's in the glass as the distillery itself. Speyside, nestled in the northeast, is known for its fertile valleys and the River Spey, producing whiskies that tend to be elegant, fruity, and approachable — often with notes of apple, pear, and rich dried fruit. Islay, a rugged island off Scotland's western coast, has earned a fierce reputation for bold, peaty expressions with a distinctly maritime character, where smoke, brine, and iodine are the calling cards. The Highlands, Scotland's largest and most varied region, defies easy categorization, offering everything from light and floral drams in the east to rich, robust whiskies in the north. Understanding these regional differences won't just help you choose a bottle — it'll deepen your appreciation for how landscape, climate, and tradition shape every single dram.

GlenAllachie 15 Year Old: Speyside Sherry at Its Most Seductive

When Master Distiller Billy Walker acquired GlenAllachie in 2017, he brought his legendary cask program with him — and the 15 Year Old is the fullest expression of that obsession. Matured in first-fill Oloroso and Pedro Ximénez sherry casks alongside red wine barrels and virgin oak, it delivers a palate of syrupy dark fruits, plum, raisin, mocha, dark chocolate, and spiced orange peel. Bottled at 46% ABV without chill filtration or added color, the mouthfeel is almost chewy — a richness that earned it 92 points from Whisky Advocate. For a region known for elegant fruit and honey, GlenAllachie 15 pushes Speyside into unexpectedly decadent territory, competing easily with sherried malts that cost far more.

Kilchoman Machir Bay: Islay's Farm Distillery Punches Above Its Weight

Founded in 2005 by Anthony and Kathy Wills, Kilchoman was the first new distillery built on Islay in over 124 years — and its Machir Bay flagship proved that youth and craft could rival decades of tradition. The distillery operates as a genuine farm-to-bottle operation, growing and malting a portion of its own barley on Rockside Farm and handling every stage of production on-site. Machir Bay is vatted from approximately 90% first-fill ex-bourbon barrels and 10% Oloroso sherry butts, bottled at 46% without chill filtration, delivering citrus zest, vanilla biscuits, coastal peat smoke, tropical fruit, and a maritime salinity that is unmistakably Islay. It has won gold at the IWSC and the International Spirits Challenge, proving it can stand alongside Islay's most established names at a fraction of the price.

Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban: The Highland That Thinks in Port

Glenmorangie has long been a gateway to Highland whisky — its distillery in Tain uses the tallest copper pot stills in Scotland, which contribute directly to the light, fruity character the house is famous for. The Quinta Ruban takes that delicate base spirit, ages it in ex-bourbon casks, then finishes it in ruby port pipes from the Quintas of the Douro Valley, adding a layer of depth that transforms the dram entirely. The result is a profile of dark chocolate, mint, orange peel, and rich berry fruit layered over Glenmorangie's signature vanilla and citrus. Bottled at 46% ABV, it rewards drinkers who find the core Original too light, offering the Highland style at its most adventurous without straying into peat or smoke.

Mortlach 16 Year Old: The Beast of Dufftown Fully Unleashed

Known in the industry as 'The Beast of Dufftown,' Mortlach has a fierce reputation built on a unique 2.81 times distillation process that no other Speyside distillery replicates, producing a spirit of exceptional weight and meatiness. For most of its history it was used almost exclusively as a backbone component in Johnnie Walker blends, making bottled single malt releases rare and highly prized before its own core range launched in 2014. The 16 Year Old tied for World's Best Scotch Whisky at the Ultimate Spirits Challenge in 2023, delivering robust notes of dried fruits, roasted nuts, malted loaf, dark red meat, and rich toffee. For drinkers who find typical Speyside too polite, Mortlach 16 is the region's most muscular and unapologetically bold statement.

Craigellachie 13 Year Old: Speyside's Most Rebellious Dram

Craigellachie spent most of its existence as a workhorse distillery supplying spirit to blenders, only beginning to bottle its own single malts in the last decade — a move that quickly built a devoted following among whisky adventurers. The distillery is one of the last in Scotland to use traditional worm-tub condensers, an old-school method that is difficult to maintain but preserves sulfurous, meaty, and robust flavors that modern condensers strip away. The 13 Year Old is the most flavor-driven and deliberately offbeat expression you will find in Speyside, built on notes of smoke, sea salt, caramelized apple, ripe peach, and a distinctive savory, spirit-forward depth. For drinkers who find standard Speyside too smooth or predictable, Craigellachie 13 is a direct and rewarding challenge to everything the region is assumed to be.

Ardbeg 10 Year Old: Islay's Peat Legend in Full Voice

Founded in 1815 on Islay's southern coast, Ardbeg was intermittently mothballed through the 1980s and 90s before being rescued by Glenmorangie and achieving cult status. The 10 Year Old is built on heavily peated malt sourced from Port Ellen, combined with long fermentation times and a distinctive purifier pipe that keeps the spirit simultaneously citrus-sweet and clean while packing an oily, tarry smoke character. On the palate you'll find waves of bonfire ash, dark chocolate, and lemon zest, with a finish that lingers long and medicinal. It represents the purest entry point into Ardbeg's house style and remains the benchmark against which every other heavily peated Islay malt is measured.

Ardnamurchan AD/ Cask Strength: The Wild West Highland Overachiever

Founded in 2014 by independent bottlers Adelphi Selection, Ardnamurchan sits on Scotland's remote western peninsula and holds the distinction of being the most westerly distillery on the UK mainland. Each numbered batch of the cask strength release is made from a marriage of peated and unpeated spirit matured in ex-bourbon barrels with a small addition of Oloroso and PX sherry casks, and comes bottled at natural cask strength with no chill filtration or artificial colouring — a commitment the distillery calls Integrity Whisky. The nose delivers cracked peppercorns, salted lemons, and crushed oyster shells with a backdrop of warm spice over a smouldering beach fire; the palate brings honey, meaty peat smoke, and a pronounced coastal minerality that speaks directly to where it was made. For a craft distillery barely a decade old, the quality and transparency of these releases have made Ardnamurchan one of the most exciting names in Scottish whisky.

Balvenie Caribbean Cask 14: Speyside Honey Gets a Rum Twist

Founded in 1892 near Dufftown, Balvenie is one of the last distilleries in Scotland to grow its own barley, operate a traditional malting floor, and manage its own cooperage — a level of hands-on control that gives its whisky a distinctive, honey-drenched consistency. The Caribbean Cask 14 was developed by longtime Master Distiller David Stewart following a research trip to Barbados, and involves finishing the spirit in casks that previously held Caribbean rum, adding a tropical dimension to Balvenie's signature style. The result is a Speyside malt that opens with vanilla, fresh apricot, and malt sweetness before the rum cask adds a warm, coconut-tinged depth and a gently spiced finish. It sits firmly in the mainstream but punches above its price point, and serves as an ideal gateway to understanding how cask finishing can transform a region's character without abandoning it.

Lagavulin 16 Year Old: Islay's Most Civilised Peat Monster

Founded around 1816 on Islay's rocky southern shore near the ruins of Dunyvaig Castle, Lagavulin holds a near-mythic status as the distillery that turned peat smoke into high art. The 16 Year Old was selected as one of Scotland's original 'Six Classic Malts' in 1988, cementing its place as a benchmark Islay expression recognised worldwide. It undergoes the slowest distillation of all Islay malts, and the result is a whisky that layers peat, leather, smoked fish, tobacco, iodine, and dark chocolate over a surprisingly refined and creamy body. What sets it apart from its louder Islay neighbours is a long-matured balance — the smoke is commanding but never coarse, underpinned by dried fruit, caramel, and a bitter-sweet, long-lingering finish. For anyone serious about understanding what Islay can do at its most composed, this is the bottle.

GlenDronach 12 Year Old: Highland Sherry Depth at an Honest Price

Founded in 1826 in the valley of Forgue, GlenDronach is one of the Highlands' earliest licensed distilleries and has been producing rich, award-winning malts ever since. The 12 Year Old is matured in a combination of Pedro Ximénez and Oloroso sherry casks, which drive the flavour profile toward dark fruits, chocolate, toffee, and a warming spiced walnut finish — everything a sherry-led Highland should deliver. It sits in an interesting position in this gallery: where Glenmorangie leans on wine casks for elegance and Ardnamurchan reaches for coastal wildness, GlenDronach 12 goes deep into the Highland tradition of robust, cask-forward richness. The distillery has changed hands over the years — most recently acquired by Brown-Forman in 2016 — but the house style, built on exclusively sherry-seasoned wood, has never wavered. It remains one of the most rewarding entry points into serious Highland whisky at a price that doesn't require a second thought.

Benromach 10 Year Old: Speyside's Quietly Rebellious Peat Whisperer

Benromach is owned by Gordon & MacPhail, the legendary Elgin-based independent family firm that rescued the distillery from closure and restarted production in 1998 after a 15-year silence. Where most Speyside distilleries lean into light, fruit-forward profiles, Benromach 10 uses a touch of lightly peated malt to add an undercurrent of bonfire smoke that sits beneath layers of tropical sweetness — a combination that is both distinctly Speyside and defiantly its own. The result is a whisky that delivers vanilla, green apple, and orchard fruit on the nose, before the palate introduces that signature gentle smoke alongside honey, citrus, and warming spice. Matured in first-fill bourbon barrels and ex-sherry casks, the 10 Year Old consistently punches above its modest price point and has drawn praise from critics looking for complexity without the premium-brand markup. It is the Speyside for drinkers who thought they had already mapped the region.

More Galleries