The Best Wheated Bourbons

The Best Wheated Bourbons

In the realm of bourbon, wheated varieties offer a sought-after smoothness and unique flavor profile. This curated selection focuses solely on taste, with accessibility factored in where possible, ensuring a reliable guide for enthusiasts looking to explore affordable options. Drawing from extensive personal experience and a keen understanding of the nuances of wheated bourbon, this list offers a trustworthy resource for selecting your next bottle.

12. Old Fitzgerald Prime

Old Fitzgerald spans the spectrum of bourbon offerings, from the pinnacle of luxury to its budget-friendly Prime expression. While Prime may not dazzle the palate like its pricier counterparts, it remains a serviceable option for mixing cocktails or enjoying neat. The nose hints at vanilla and oak, with a subtle spice on the palate, though its lower proof and restrained flavor profile relegate it to the bottom of this list. Despite its modest merits, Prime receives minimal promotion and is increasingly scarce. While it's a decent choice for those seeking an affordable bourbon, those in search of more exemplary examples of wheated bourbon should continue their exploration. Buy it now!

11. McKenzie Bottled in Bond Bourbon

While Kentucky remains synonymous with bourbon, exceptional expressions can be found beyond its borders, such as this whiskey from Finger Lakes Distilling in New York. Paying homage to the Bottled in Bond Act of 1897, McKenzie adheres to strict standards, aging for at least four years and bottled at 100 proof. This results in a robust yet soft wheated bourbon, boasting a subtle char aroma and delicate notes of honey, butterscotch, cinnamon, and nutmeg on the palate. While lacking the balance of some competitors and facing limited availability outside New York, McKenzie offers a satisfying alternative for bourbon enthusiasts seeking diversity in their collection. Buy it now!

10. Larceny Small Batch

The Larceny Kentucky Straight Bourbon, steeped in historical legacy, traces its roots back to John E. Fitzgerald, a post-Civil War distiller who founded a distillery along the Kentucky River. Fitzgerald's Old Fitzgerald Bourbon, renowned for its quality, eventually landed in the hands of Julian P. "Pappy" Van Winkle, sealing its fate as one of the world's most celebrated bourbons. Larceny pays homage to Fitzgerald's discerning taste and the Old Fitzgerald brand, incorporating a unique mash of corn, wheat, malted barley, and rye. Distilled in Kentucky limestone water and fermented with a proprietary yeast strain, Larceny honors tradition by choosing wheat as its secondary grain, creating a distinctive and flavorful bourbon. Buy it now!

9. David Nicholson 1843

Named after a storied distiller who pioneered bourbon-making in St. Louis, David Nicholson 1843, now crafted by Lux Row Distillers, embodies the smoothness beloved by wheated bourbon enthusiasts. Bottled at 100 proof, it offers excellent quality at an affordable price, presented in a classic bottle design with a vintage-inspired label. With a buttery aroma and a rich mouthfeel, it delivers sweet flavors, notably honey, complemented by mild spice and oak warmth. While not as complex as some counterparts and subject to limited availability in certain regions, David Nicholson 1843 offers a distinct option for those seeking a unique bourbon experience. Buy it now!

8. Nine Banded Wheated Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Nine Banded offers a distinctive take on wheated bourbon, with a modern design setting it apart from traditional counterparts. Launched in 2019 by a Texas-based brand, this expression features a high wheat content of 45%, lending it a rich mouthfeel and approachable elegance. Named after the nine-banded armadillo and utilizing limestone-filtered Texan spring water, it boasts a unique water source that contributes to its flavorful profile. Notes of vanilla, honey, clove, and citrus dominate the palate, although lacking depth, while its luxurious texture and earthy finish ensure a satisfying drinking experience. Despite limited availability, its affordability makes it a worthy addition to any bourbon enthusiast's collection. Buy it now!

7. Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Crafted by Bill Samuels, Sr. with the intent of making a bourbon that he would personally savor, Maker's Mark stands out for its smooth and approachable nature, offering an easy finish that was revolutionary compared to the prevalent hot and harsh whiskies of its time. Produced gradually in small batches within our National Historic Landmark distillery in Loretto, Kentucky, Maker's Mark has become a staple in enhancing various cocktails. Nevertheless, many enthusiasts still prefer to enjoy it neat or over ice with a splash of water, highlighting its versatility and appeal as a standalone whiskey. Buy it now!

6. Green River Distilling Co. Wheated Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Green River Distilling Co. presents an intriguing addition to the wheated bourbon category, with its namesake inspired by Kentucky's Green River. Founded in 1885, the brand underwent a hiatus until its revival in 2014, with bottles hitting the market in 2022. Despite its relatively recent resurgence, the brand has quickly gained traction. The wheated bourbon boasts a mash bill comprising 21% wheat, 70% corn, and 9% malted barley. A surprising fruitiness, reminiscent of peach, greets the nose, complemented by notes of toasted oak and nutmeg. On the palate, honey sweetness prevails, accompanied by a hint of nuttiness that adds warmth. While its availability may pose a challenge, and its complexity falls short of top-tier contenders, this expression underscores the wisdom of reviving this historic brand. Buy it now!

5. Frey Ranch Straight Bourbon

Wheated bourbons typically replace rye with wheat in the mash bill, alongside corn and barley. However, some expressions, like Frey Ranch Straight Bourbon, incorporate all four grains, aiming for a harmonious blend. This bourbon, crafted in Fallon, Nevada, distinguishes itself further by sourcing all grains on-site, adding a unique touch to its production process. Encased in an elegantly designed bottle, the presentation enhances the allure of this expression. Upon pouring, it entices with a bouquet featuring citrus and orange notes, subtly intertwined with oak and spice undertones. The palate offers a rich tapestry of flavors, including banana, complemented by cedar and pepper complexities. With a commitment to sustainable grain cultivation, Frey Ranch appeals to environmentally conscious consumers, while its quality makes it a standout choice for bourbon enthusiasts. Availability challenges and a more subdued flavor profile might deter those seeking bolder whiskey experiences, but overall, it's an exceptional bourbon worthy of attention. Buy it now!

4. Wyoming Whiskey

As demonstrated, exceptional wheated bourbon extends beyond Kentucky, exemplified by Wyoming Whiskey. With a mash bill featuring 20% wheat, it embodies the rugged essence of the American West. The aroma delights with rich caramel and vanilla tones, accompanied by subtle floral nuances. Despite its 88-proof strength, the initial sip reveals a robust character, showcasing a well-balanced interplay of flavors across the palate. Dark chocolate, dried fruits, and cinnamon emerge, offering a satisfying complexity. While the finish may be relatively short, it doesn't detract significantly from the overall experience, especially considering its mid-range pricing. Wyoming Whiskey's boldness sets it apart, catering to varied palates, and its utilization of pristine water from a deep limestone aquifer adds to its allure. A charming brand with high-quality bourbon, it's certainly worthy of a coveted spot on any whiskey enthusiast's wish list. Buy it now!

3. Rebel Small Batch Reserve

Rebel Bourbon's small batch expression, distilled by Lux Row Distillers, embodies boldness with its robust 110 proof and rich flavor profile. Rooted in a recipe dating back to 1849, this bourbon delivers classic notes of syrup, dark fruits, and cinnamon, culminating in a warm, smooth finish. While its intensity may be too much for some, those craving power and complexity in their bourbon will find Rebel Small Batch Reserve to be an excellent choice, offering exceptional value for its adventurous spirit and nuanced taste. Buy it now!

2. Redemption Wheated Bourbon

Redemption Wheated Bourbon stands out as a hidden gem among bourbon brands, offering exceptional quality at a modest price point. While Redemption typically focuses on spicier rye whiskies, this expression, rich with 45% wheat, presents a smooth and delightful alternative. The nose captivates with prominent vanilla notes complemented by hints of burnt wood, pear, and subtle florals, setting the stage for a truly enjoyable tasting experience. Upon tasting, its sweetness unfolds gracefully, accompanied by a luxurious mouthfeel and a harmonious blend of chocolate, hazelnut, and warming spices like nutmeg and black pepper. With each sip, the finish leaves a lingering desire for more, showcasing the whiskey's depth and allure. While it may fall just short of claiming the top spot, Redemption Wheated Bourbon undoubtedly earns its place as a top-tier choice for bourbon enthusiasts seeking something beyond the mainstream. Buy it now!

1. Maker's Mark Cask Strength

At a robust 108 to 114 proof, Maker's Mark® Cask Strength intensifies the front-of-the-palate flavors characteristic of Maker's Mark®. In essence, it's Maker's™ with an abundance of Maker's™. However, the focal point isn't merely the elevated alcohol content; it's the remarkable taste. Maker's Mark® Cask Strength amplifies the signature flavors of rich oak, vanilla, caramel, and spice that define the distinctive profile of Maker's Mark®, delivering a bold and intensified expression of the beloved classic. Buy it now!