Hidden Gem Bourbons That Experts Rate Highly

Highly Rated Bourbons - Some You Have Never Heard Of

Here is a list of some bourbons that are highly rated (above 90 points) by Wine Enthusiast or the The Tasting Panel from Total Wine. These are all pretty available and I bet some of these you have never heard of and most of these are quite afforadable as well.

Elijah Craig 18 Year Bourbon (98 Points)

Cognac aficionados will appreciate the dry pallete, nose, and buttery vanilla nose notes with a touch of caramel. It's sweet, smokey, and has an endless aftertaste. Buy it now!

Kentucky Owl Takumi Edition Bourbon (97 Points)

From a Japanese perspective, this US Bourbon adds the finest aspects of Japanese whiskey production to Kentucky Owl's limited-edition bourbon line. Japanese Master Blender Yahisa Yusuke has teamed up with their Master Blender Joh Rhea. Tasting Panel 2022. Buy it now!

Redemption High Rye Bourbon (96 Points)

Nose: A trace of oak, red berry fruitiness, and subtle vanilla. Palate: Notes of mint, oak, and spice. overtones of black pepper from the rye and subtle licorice that resemble fennel. The high rye percentage gives it a pleasant spiciness in the long, silky finish. Buy it now!

American Brick Spirits Straight Bourbon Whiskey (96 Points)

Bourbon made from 100% New York grain to glass. made using a four-grain mix and adorned with Hudson Valley crisp mineral water. A smooth sipper, it's deep and doughy with subtle aromas of toasted wood, butterscotch, and sweet cedar. 96 points, Gold SFWSC. Buy it now!

Wolcott Kentucky Straight Bourbon (95 Points)

Originating from the renowned Barton 1792 Distillery, this Blue Grass gem has a dry and spicy character thanks to warming aromas of vanilla, caramel, and a pleasant bite of rye. With a hint of apricot at the end and sweet corn colored with berries, the palate is zesty. SFWSC Gold. Buy it now!

Bondstone Double Oak Bourbon (95 Points)

Re-barreled for additional flavor and character after being aged in excellent fresh charred American oak barrels. The subtle, sweet oaky aromas that are bolstered by rye spice, caramel, and cinnamon are enhanced by this re-barrel. Excellent for sipping and enjoying on rocks. Gold Double-SFWSCC. Buy it now!

RD One Small Batch Brazillian Amburana Wood Bourbon (95 Points)

The aroma is filled with the finest baking spices, such as apple cinnamon, nutmeg, and light brown sugar. Pine, vanilla, peaches, and apricots follow. Spice cake, ginger snaps, and a creamy texture provide tons of flavor. Buy it now!

Iron Smoke Straight Bourbon Whiskey (95 Points)

Limited batches of this handcrafted, four-grain straight bourbon are proudly distilled. use only fresh grains from nearby Upstate farms. With a hint of apple wood smoke toward the end, it's deliciously smooth. The 2018 Jim Murray Whiskey Bible received a rating of 95.5. Buy it now!

Bank Street 5 Year Reserve Bourbon (94 Points)

A good Kentucky Bourbon that has been matured for at least five years. Savor hints of caramel, brown sugar, vanilla, and charred wood. Ideal for your preferred mixed drinks, such as a Manhattan and an Old Fashioned. Selected by Wine Enthusiast as a Best Buy! Wine Enthusiast (94 points). Buy it now!

Still Austin Straight Bourbon Whiskey (94 Points)

This pure bourbon is more than simply corn, rye, and malted barley from Texas; it's a bottle of song. We suggest listening to a record you enjoy when you sample our whiskey. Buy it now!

I. W. Harper 15 Year Bourbon (94 Points)

I.W. Harper 15 Year Old Kentucky Straight whiskey Whiskey is a sophisticated whiskey that is ideal for life's finest occasions, with a depth of flavor and history that only the I.W. Harper brand can offer. There is a rich, fruity scent on the nostrils. Buy it now!

Clyde May's Straight Bourbon (94 Points)

This five-year-old straight bourbon with no chill filter is an immediate classic. A rich mouthfeel and a lengthy, delectable finish are accompanied by a soft nose with notes of strawberry, baked apricot, and nutmeg. Winner of the 2016 Ultimate Spirits Challenge Gold Medal. Buy it now!

Chestnut Farms Bottled in Bond Bourbon (93 Points)

Located in Bardstown, Kentucky, this six-year hi-rye bourbon is made and matured on-site at the renowned Barton 1792 Distillery. 100PF-bottled. Custard and ripe fruit flavors combine with a complex vanilla and mint scent. strong, substantial mouthfeel and residue. SFWSC's Double Gold. Buy it now!

Bib & Tucker 6 Year Bourbon (93 Points)

A lovely scent of leather-bound books, freshly cut grass, and vanilla. The palate is dominated by notes of caramel, dried apricots, vanilla beans, and sweet fruit, with a little hint of ginger spice. With notes of corn and chestnuts, the finish is nuanced and persistent. Buy it now!

First Call Double Oak Bourbon (93 Points)

To bring out the deep notes of vanilla, caramel, and toasty wood, this 90 proof bourbon expression is double barreled in oak barrels. notes of dried fruit in a complex aftertaste. It's ideal for sipping neat or on the rocks to fully enjoy its richness. SFWSC Gold. Buy it now!

High West Double Rye Barrel Select Bourbon

Rich vanilla and caramel underpin the delectably robust spice flavor of High West Double Rye Barrel Select Whiskey. Extra barrel age adds a special level of flavor depth and complexity. Buy it now!

More Galleries