Bartenders Pick Their Doomsday Bunker Bottle of Bourbon

Bartenders Pick Their Doomsday Bunker Bottle of Bourbon

If the world’s going down tomorrow, what bourbon would you want stashed in your bunker to sip while watching the chaos? We hit up some seasoned bartenders across the country and asked ’em straight: what’s the one bottle you’d grab if it was the end times? These guys pour drinks for a living, so they know their stuff. Turns out, it’s a mix of reliable everyday heroes and those rare beauties worth saving for the apocalypse. Me, I remember cracking open a bottle of Blanton’s one rough night after a long week – just sitting on the porch, pouring a generous glass, and letting the day melt away. Felt like nothing else mattered. Here’s what the pros said they’d bunker down with.

Blanton’s Single Barrel

This one comes up a lot when bartenders talk about something special but still drinkable. Blanton’s is that smooth, rich pour with notes of caramel, vanilla, and a little spice that hits just right. It’s got that single-barrel magic where every bottle’s a bit different, but always classy – perfect for slow sipping when you’re reflecting on life (or what’s left of it). Not too overpowering, but full of flavor that makes you forget the zombies outside for a minute. Plenty of pros call it their go-to for a reason; it’s the kind of bourbon that feels like a treat without trying too hard.

Barrell Craft Spirits Bourbon

If you’re leaning craft, bartenders point to Barrell’s batches as killer options. These are masterful blends from sourced barrels, delivering big complexity with vanilla, dark fruit, and spice that evolves in the glass. It’s bold yet balanced, the kinda pour that stands out in a sea of big names – great for savoring when supplies are limited and you want something unique to mark the occasion.

Elijah Craig Barrel Proof

If you want something with serious kick, this is the beast a few bartenders swore by for doomsday. Uncut and unfiltered, it comes in hot – usually around 120-140 proof depending on the batch – packing big oak, dark fruit, and baking spices that’ll warm you up from the inside out. It’s intense, yeah, but in the best way; you can sip it neat if you’re tough or add a drop of water to open it up. Bartenders love it ’cause it stands up to anything, whether you’re nursing it straight or stretching it in tough times. One guy even said it’d double as a weapon if things got real bad – talk about versatile.

Frey Ranch Straight Bourbon

From a true grain-to-glass farm distillery in Nevada, this one’s got that earthy depth with caramel, corn sweetness, and a touch of smoke. It’s smooth for its proof, full-bodied, and super sipable – bartenders dig it for representing real craft without the hype. In a bunker, it’d feel like a taste of the open land you’re missing.

Wild Turkey Rare Breed

A bunch of folks behind the bar rave about this barrel-proof gem from Wild Turkey. It’s bold and spicy with that classic Turkey bite – think deep caramel, pepper, and toasted oak that lingers forever. Not watered down, so it’s got real punch, but it’s surprisingly smooth for the proof. Perfect for guys who like their bourbon with some attitude; it’s affordable enough to stock a few, but premium enough to feel special when the grid goes dark. Bartenders dig it for tailgates or cigars normally, but in a bunker? It’d keep things interesting night after night.

Smoke Wagon Small Batch

This Nevada craft standout brings rich caramel, rye spice, and a creamy texture that punches way up. Bartenders love its balance and boldness – it’s got that small-batch character without being over the top. Tough to beat for long-term sipping when you need something reliable with flair.

Michter’s 10 Year Old

For the ones going all-in on luxury, Michter’s 10 showed up as a top pick. This is mature, complex stuff – loads of dried fruit, chocolate, and vanilla from all that time in the barrel. It’s silky on the tongue with a long, warm finish that makes you savor every drop. Bartenders call it thoughtful and refined, the kind you pull out when you want to appreciate the good things, even if the world’s ending. Hard to find sometimes, but worth hunting for; it’s like the quiet leader in a lineup of loud bottles.

Starlight Distillery Bourbon

Coming from a family-run Indiana operation, their aged expressions deliver deep oak, fruit, and caramel with real elegance. It’s craft at its finest – nuanced and rewarding, perfect for those reflective bunker nights when you want depth without the big-brand feel.

E.H. Taylor Small Batch

This Buffalo Trace classic got nods for its consistency and old-school charm. Bottled-in-bond, so it’s always 100 proof with flavors of butterscotch, oak, and a touch of spice that never lets you down. It’s got history behind it, named after the colonel who shaped modern bourbon. Bartenders love pouring it ’cause it’s reliable – great neat, on the rocks, or in a simple cocktail if you’ve got mixers left. In a bunker scenario, it’s the solid choice that won’t disappoint, no matter how many times you reach for it.

Frank August Small Batch

A newer craft player that’s turning heads with its modern take – smooth, balanced with vanilla, spice, and a clean finish. Bartenders praise its sophistication and drinkability; it’s the kinda bottle that feels premium but approachable, ideal for stretching out in hard times.

Four Roses Single Barrel

A favorite for its fruity, spicy edge thanks to that higher rye. You get bright apple, floral notes, and pepper that keeps things lively. Every barrel’s unique, but they’re all balanced and easy to drink at 100 proof. Bartenders swear by it for versatility – sips clean or mixes like a champ. If you’re hunkered down long-term, this one’d stay exciting without overwhelming you. It’s the under-the-radar pick that punches way above its weight.

Wyoming Whiskey Small Batch

True craft from out west, using local grains for a wheated profile that’s soft with vanilla, caramel, and subtle fruit. It’s clean and comforting – bartenders like it for its purity and how it shines neat. In the bunker, it’d be that easy-drinking companion for the long haul.

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked

This one’s for the guys who crave something richer. Woodford takes their standard bourbon and finishes it in heavily toasted barrels, pulling out big vanilla, chocolate, and caramel vibes with a creamy mouthfeel. It’s smooth as heck, almost dessert-like, but still got enough depth to keep you coming back. Bartenders like it for special pours ’cause it impresses without being flashy. In the end days, it’d be that comforting bottle you turn to when you need a hug in liquid form.

Milam & Greene Bourbon

Texas craft with big personality – rich toffee, spice, and oak from careful blending. It’s versatile and flavorful, the type bartenders recommend for its warmth and complexity. Perfect bunker pick for when you want that extra layer of comfort in every glass.

More Galleries