Award-Winning Whiskeys For The Cost Of Dinner

Award-Winning Whiskeys For The Cost Of Dinner

Look, I get it. You're standing in the liquor store, staring at bottles that cost more than a car payment, and wondering if there's anything decent that won't require you to eat ramen for the rest of the month. Here's the thing – you don't need to drop a hundred bucks or more to get your hands on some seriously good whiskey. I remember the first time I realized this, actually standing in a liquor store in Kentucky, complaining to my buddy about prices. The guy behind the counter just smiled and pointed me toward a bottle that ran about forty bucks. Changed everything for me. Turns out, there's a whole world of award-winning whiskeys out there that clock in around the price of a decent dinner or what you'd spend filling up your tank – roughly $40 give or take. These aren't your bottom-shelf mixers, either. We're talking legit, award-winning stuff that's been recognized by competitions and judges who know their business. So let's dive into some bottles that'll make your wallet and your taste buds equally happy.

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon

This is the bottle that's been quietly crushing it for years while everyone else chases the allocated stuff. Buffalo Trace has been making whiskey at their Frankfort, Kentucky location for over two centuries, and they've got the whole process down to a science at this point. You're looking at around $25 to $30 for a bottle, which is basically a steal considering what you're getting. The distillery uses their classic mash bill and ages this bourbon for around eight years, though they don't slap an age statement on it. What you end up with is caramel and vanilla on the nose, with some warm spices and a hint of mint coming through. The palate brings butter toffee and fruit cake, and the finish sticks around just long enough to remind you why this bottle keeps winning awards. It's one of those whiskeys that works great neat, on the rocks, or in a cocktail, which makes it pretty versatile for whatever mood you're in. The fact that it regularly shows up on "best whiskey under $50" lists from major competitions isn't an accident.

Four Roses Single Barrel

Four Roses doesn't mess around with their single barrel offerings, and the price point sits right around $40 to $45 depending on where you shop. In 2025, they expanded the line to include OESK, OBSF, and OESO recipes alongside their original OBSV, which means there's more variety than ever before. Each one brings something a little different to the table based on their specific mash bill and yeast combination, but they all share that signature Four Roses quality. The OBSV, which has been around the longest, delivers delicate herbal rye and fruit notes with moderately dense honey, apple, and vanilla sweetness. You'll pick up oak, cinnamon, and clove spices along with some mint and berries that keep things interesting. At 100 proof, it's got enough backbone to stand up without being aggressive. Recent reviews have called three out of four of these expressions "Top Shelf," which is about as good as it gets for a readily available $50 bourbon. The fact that you can actually find these on shelves instead of hunting them down like some kind of whiskey detective makes them even more appealing.

FEW Bourbon

Here's where craft distilling gets real interesting. FEW Spirits operates out of Evanston, Illinois – literally the birthplace of the Temperance movement – in what used to be a chop shop down a back alley. Talk about poetic justice. Founder Paul Hletko started this operation in 2011 as the first distillery in the area since Prohibition got repealed, and he's been making grain-to-glass whiskey ever since. The standard FEW Bourbon runs you about $40 and uses 70% corn, 20% rye, and 10% malted barley, all sourced locally. The rye percentage is higher than your typical bourbon, which brings more spice to the party alongside the vanilla and caramel you'd expect. This stuff has picked up awards at the Whiskies of the World competition and earned gold medals for its bold, spicy profile. What makes it stand out is that Chicago-style twist – it's got more attitude than your standard Kentucky bourbon, with a richer mouthfeel and complexity that comes from their unique fermentation process. The smaller barrel aging also concentrates the flavors faster, so you're getting more bang for your buck in terms of taste development.

Old Overholt Rye

If you want to talk about history in a bottle, Old Overholt has been around since 1810 when Abe Overholt started making rye whiskey in West Overton, Pennsylvania. This is one of those classic American rye whiskeys that bartenders keep behind the bar because it just works. At roughly $22, it's actually well under the $40 mark, which leaves you room to grab something else or just save the difference. The 4-year age statement and 86 proof make it approachable without being watered down, and the flavor profile leans heavy into that spicy rye character. You'll get black pepper and black figs on the nose, followed by a rich palate that carries those dark fruit and spice notes through to a lingering finish. The complexity here is surprising for the price point – it's not trying to be subtle or refined, it's just bold and honest about what it is. Bartenders love it for cocktails, but it holds up perfectly fine on its own if you're into rye's more assertive personality. For around twenty bucks, you're getting a piece of American whiskey history that still competes with bottles costing twice as much.

Maker's Mark Cask Strength

People lose their minds over Weller, camping out at liquor stores and paying secondary market prices that make no sense. Meanwhile, Maker's Mark Cask Strength sits on shelves for $50 to $55 and delivers everything you'd want from a wheated bourbon without the hassle. This is the full-proof version of Maker's standard offering, bottled straight from the barrel without any water added, which means you're getting it exactly as it came out of the cask. The wheated mash bill gives it that characteristic sweetness and smoothness, with loads of caramel, oak spice (especially cinnamon), nuttiness, and a solid alcohol kick that reminds you this isn't your average pour. Head-to-head comparisons with Weller Antique 107 have actually favored Maker's Mark Cask Strength, and you don't have to hunt for it or pay inflated prices. The cask strength format lets you control the experience too – add water or ice if you want to open it up, or drink it neat if you're feeling brave. Either way, you're getting a premium wheated bourbon experience that respects both your palate and your budget. It's one of those bottles that makes you wonder why anyone bothers with the allocated stuff.

W.L. Weller Special Reserve

The "Green Label" Weller is the original wheated bourbon that started everything, and if you can find it at retail (around $25 to $30), it's absolutely worth grabbing. This comes from Buffalo Trace Distillery, the same folks who make Pappy Van Winkle, which explains why people get so excited about it. The wheated mash bill creates a smoother, sweeter profile compared to rye-heavy bourbons, with warm amber color and notes of caramel and sourdough bread on the nose. The palate delivers rich dessert tones like toffee, butterscotch, nutmeg, and toasted wood, while the finish is shorter but leaves you with lingering floral notes of jasmine and honeysuckle. Now, here's the catch – availability can be spotty because everyone's trying to get their hands on anything with the Weller name. But if you do spot it at a reasonable price, don't hesitate. It's smooth enough for beginners but interesting enough for experienced whiskey drinkers, and it gives you a taste of that famous wheated bourbon style without requiring you to win a lottery or know someone who knows someone.

1792 Small Batch

Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown is Kentucky's oldest fully operating distillery, dating back to 1879, and their Small Batch expression shows exactly why they've lasted this long. At $30 to $35, you're getting a high-rye bourbon that's thought to contain whiskey aged between four and eight years, though there's no official age statement on the bottle. That rye content, estimated between 15 and 25%, brings spice to balance out the sweetness, and at 93.7 proof it's got enough strength to make an impression without being harsh. Recent awards from the Top Shelf Awards Gala recognized this as one of the best bourbons in its age category, with tasting notes pointing to sweet vanilla, caramelized sugar, cherries, tobacco, brown spice, honey, and wheat. The distillery blends this in limited quantities to maintain consistency across batches, which means you can trust that what you buy this month will taste pretty similar to what you buy next year. It's a reliable core expression that punches above its weight class, and the awards keep proving it belongs in conversations about quality bourbon regardless of price.

Mellow Corn Bottled-in-Bond

This might be the most underrated bottle on this entire list. Mellow Corn is a straight corn whiskey from Heaven Hill that runs about $15, and bartenders across the country have been quietly stocking it for years. One bartender called it Heaven Hill's "forehead kiss to bartenders," which pretty much sums up how the industry feels about it. The bottled-in-bond designation means it meets strict quality standards – distilled at one distillery during one season, aged at least four years in a federal bonded warehouse, and bottled at 100 proof. The mash bill is 80% corn, 12% malted barley, and 8% rye, and unlike bourbon, it ages in used barrels rather than new ones. This gives it a lighter oak influence and lets the sweet, grain-forward corn flavor really shine through. There's no pretense here, no fancy marketing or limited releases – it's just sessionable, charming corn whiskey that tastes good and doesn't try to be something it's not. At $15, it's literally less than lunch at most places, and it delivers way more personality than you'd expect at that price point. Don't sleep on this one just because it's cheap.

Noble Oak Double Oak Bourbon

Noble Oak comes from Newtown, Ohio, and it's been quietly racking up awards including double-gold recognition for its unique aging process. This bourbon gets matured in new charred oak barrels like you'd expect, but then it goes into a second set of new charred oak barrels for additional aging. That double-barrel treatment deepens the color and intensifies flavors of caramel, vanilla, and oak spice beyond what you'd normally get. At around $40, it's positioned perfectly in that value sweet spot where quality meets affordability. The extended oak contact brings more complexity without making it overly woody or tannic, and there's a richness to the mouthfeel that makes it feel more expensive than it actually is. This is relatively new to the market compared to some of the heritage brands, but it's already making waves in competitions and earning shelf space based purely on merit. If you're looking for something a little different that still delivers classic bourbon characteristics, Noble Oak offers a fresh take on traditional production methods without charging you an arm and a leg for the privilege.

Jack Daniel's Single Barrel

Here's the thing about Jack Daniel's – most people write it off as the stuff you mixed with Coke in college, but the Single Barrel expression is a completely different animal. This runs around $40 and represents the richer, more complex version of what the distillery can do when they're not trying to make something for the masses. You're getting denser caramel, vanilla, and oak spices compared to the standard offerings, plus some fruit notes that add depth most people don't associate with the brand. The single barrel selection means each bottle comes from one specific barrel rather than being blended, so there's more character and variation from bottle to bottle. It's Tennessee whiskey, which means it goes through the Lincoln County Process of charcoal filtering before aging, giving it a smoother profile than straight bourbon. If you've only ever had Old No. 7, this will change your opinion of what Jack Daniel's can produce. The distillery's been making whiskey since the 1860s, and this expression shows they still know what they're doing when they're not focused on mass market appeal.

More Galleries