7 Rye Whiskeys Every Bourbon Drinker Should Try Now
Why Bourbon Drinkers Should Give Rye a Serious Chance
Rye whiskey and bourbon share the same American DNA — new charred oak barrels, similar distillation methods, and a devotion to grain — but rye turns the flavor dial in a distinctly different direction. Where bourbon leans on corn's natural sweetness, rye brings peppery spice, herbal complexity, and a drier finish that rewards the palate in ways corn-heavy mashes simply can't. The category has exploded in recent years, with craft distilleries and legacy producers alike releasing age-stated and barrel-finished expressions that rival the finest bourbons on the shelf. If you already love the caramel, vanilla, and oak of bourbon, rye offers a logical and exciting next step — familiar enough to feel comfortable, different enough to keep you reaching for another pour. The seven bottles here represent some of the most compelling reasons to make the leap.
WhistlePig 10 Year: The Rye That Converts Bourbon Loyalists
WhistlePig's flagship 10-year expression is one of the most talked-about rye whiskeys in the country, and for good reason — it delivers a nose of almonds, mint, citrus, and molasses sweetness that feels immediately approachable rather than aggressively spicy. Distilled in Alberta, Canada from a 100% rye mashbill, the whiskey is finished, blended, and bottled at the brand's farm in Shoreham, Vermont, where the operation launched its first on-site production in 2015. At 50% ABV, it carries enough backbone to sip neat while remaining versatile enough for serious cocktail work. Bourbon drinkers will find familiar caramel and vanilla notes on the palate, but the rye spice, oily mouthfeel, and pine-and-peppermint finish mark it as something entirely its own. It's the kind of bottle that earns permanent shelf space once it's been opened. Buy it now!
Colonel E.H. Taylor Straight Rye: Buffalo Trace's Bourbon-Friendly Rye
Produced at Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, Kentucky, the Colonel E.H. Taylor Straight Rye is a 100-proof, bottled-in-bond expression that pays tribute to the legendary distiller who shaped what would eventually become one of America's most celebrated distilleries. Unlike many ryes that lean on a corn-heavy mash to soften the grain's bite, this one uses a mashbill of rye and malted barley only — no corn — which gives it a distinctly drier, more grain-forward personality. Reviewers consistently note a fruit-forward nose of cherry, baking spices, clove, and caramel, with an oily mouthfeel and rye spice that never fully overwhelms the sweetness. The finish brings oak dryness that lingers just long enough to remind you this is a serious whiskey. For bourbon drinkers already familiar with the broader Buffalo Trace lineup, it's a natural and rewarding crossover pick. Buy it now!
High West Double Rye: Utah's Best Gateway Bottle
High West, Utah's pioneering whiskey distillery, built its reputation on expertly blended rye whiskeys, and the Double Rye is the expression that started it all. The blend combines two very different rye mashbills: a young two-year-old rye at 95% rye and 5% barley malt, and a mature 16-year-old rye with a lower 53% rye and 37% corn content. The older, corn-influenced component introduces the sweetness and extra age that bourbon drinkers instinctively gravitate toward, while the younger, high-rye spirit delivers the pepper, pine, and herbal punch that makes rye worth exploring. Bottled at 92 proof, it presents an intriguing nose of eucalyptus, aniseed, and classic spicy rye cereal with rounding vanilla and fudge. It's complex without being intimidating, and widely available at a price point that makes it an easy first commitment to the category. Buy it now!
Smooth Ambler Contradiction Rye: Appalachian Craft With Serious Credentials
Smooth Ambler Distillery operates out of Maxwelton, West Virginia, and their Contradiction Rye lives up to its name by blending a West Virginia-distilled rye with sourced whiskeys from Indiana and Tennessee — a multi-state collaboration that earned the expression a Gold medal at the 2024 World Whiskies Awards. Bottled at 52.5% ABV, it hits a proof sweet spot that amplifies flavor without punishing the palate. Reviewers note that the higher proof actually softens the expected spice kick on the nose while letting the rye assert itself clearly on the palate, delivering toasted coconut, vanilla, and caramel notes that will feel familiar to bourbon drinkers. The mouthfeel is notably creamy and well-rounded, with a nicely lingering finish that the distillery themselves recommend for Manhattan and Old Fashioned applications. It's a craft bottle with mainstream accessibility, and one of the most compelling arguments for exploring independent American rye.
Sagamore Spirit Straight Rye: Maryland Style for the Bourbon-Minded
Sagamore Spirit has made it their mission to revive Maryland-style rye whiskey, a historically distinct American rye tradition known for its balanced, mellow, and sweeter character compared to the more aggressive Pennsylvania or Kentucky styles. The base expression blends two straight rye mash bills — one high-rye at 95% and one lower-rye — both aged four to six years in high-char American oak barrels, then proofed with limestone spring water drawn from the 1909 spring house at Maryland's Sagamore Farm. The result is a whiskey with warm cinnamon, vanilla bean, honey, and nutmeg on the nose, and a smooth palate of caramel, molasses, and peppery baking spice that bourbon lovers will immediately recognize as approachable territory. At 83 proof, it's an easy-drinking bottle that works neat, on the rocks, or in cocktails, and the Tasting Panel Magazine awarded it a 95/100 for good reason. Bourbon drinkers unfamiliar with rye's softer side will find Sagamore an ideal and non-threatening introduction. Buy it now!
Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye: Barrel Proof Power With Familiar DNA
Wild Turkey's Master Distiller Jimmy Russell reportedly wasn't a natural fan of rye, but the Rare Breed Rye stands as proof that the Lawrenceburg, Kentucky distillery more than excels in the category. A barrel-proof, non-chill-filtered expression, Rare Breed Rye delivers all the intensity that bourbon drinkers expect from the Wild Turkey brand, but with the herbal, spiced complexity that makes rye a compelling alternative. Reviewers frequently place it among the best evergreen rye expressions available, noting that it punches well above its weight and is frequently overlooked in favor of its equally celebrated bourbon counterpart. The bottle has earned consistent top-tier rankings in annual rye roundups, praised for its balance of peppery rye spice, fruit, and the deep oak presence you'd expect from a brand with Wild Turkey's barrel-forward legacy. For bourbon drinkers who like their whiskey bold and unfiltered, this is the rye that will feel most like home. Buy it now!
Widow Jane Paradigm Rye: Brooklyn's Award-Winning Blending Masterclass
Widow Jane operates out of Brooklyn, New York, where the team has built a reputation for sourcing exceptional casks of American whiskey and blending them into expressions that reflect a distinct house style rather than a single distillery's character. The Paradigm Rye is the brand's no-age-statement rye offering, and it took home a Gold medal and the No Age Statement Rye Category Winner title at the 2024 World Whiskies Awards. Tasting notes from the judging panel read like a sensory tour: lemon meringue pie, spring flowers, lychee, buttered rye toast, mandarin marmalade, white pepper, and sandalwood — a profile that manages to be simultaneously bright, complex, and richly satisfying. For bourbon drinkers, the combination of baked sweetness, fruit, and restrained spice makes it an inviting departure from corn-heavy expressions. At around $37, it's also one of the best-value award-winning rye bottles on the market right now. Buy it now!
More Galleries