13 Rare Bourbons You'd Be Lucky To Find
13 Rare Bourbons You'd Be Lucky To Find
Bourbon hunting can be a real thrill, especially when you're chasing down those bottles that hardly ever show up on shelves. Back in my younger days, I remember stumbling across a dusty old Pappy at a small liquor store out in the countryside – cracked it open with some buddies around a campfire, and man, that was a night I'll never forget. These days, the truly rare ones are tougher to snag, but if you do, it's like hitting the jackpot. Here's a roundup of 13 standout rare bourbons that any serious fan would love to get their hands on.
Pappy Van Winkle 23 Year Old
This one's the king of the hill when it comes to wheated bourbons, aged a full 23 years for that deep, smooth complexity. You get waves of rich caramel, vanilla, and dark fruit on the nose, with a palate that layers in oak, honey, and a touch of spice that lingers forever – it's bold yet incredibly balanced, making every sip feel like a special occasion, though good luck finding it without some serious connections or deep pockets.
George T. Stagg (BTAC)
Part of Buffalo Trace's legendary Antique Collection, this uncut, unfiltered beast often clocks in over 130 proof and delivers massive flavors of dark chocolate, cherry, and toasted oak. The intensity hits you right away with big barrel char and spice, but it mellows into sweet toffee and leather on the finish – it's a powerhouse that's worth the hype if you can track down a bottle from the latest release.
William Larue Weller (BTAC)
Another wheated gem from the Antique Collection, this one brings soft vanilla and caramel upfront, backed by bold cinnamon and nutmeg from the high proof. Aged over a decade, it has that creamy mouthfeel with hints of dried fruit and oak that build into a long, warm finish – perfect for folks who want richness without the rye kick.
Eagle Rare 17 Year Old (BTAC)
This high-aged beauty starts with aromas of old leather, tobacco, and ripe cherry, then opens up on the palate with sweet corn, vanilla, and a peppery rye edge. The extra years in the barrel give it incredible depth and elegance, ending in a smooth, oaky fade that's just downright satisfying.
Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye (BTAC)
Even though it's a rye, this barrel-proof monster from the Antique Collection packs herbal spice, dill, and bold rye grain notes alongside sweet caramel. It's fiery and complex, with a punch of cinnamon and mint that makes it stand out – a favorite for anyone who likes their whiskey with some attitude.
E.H. Taylor Bottled in Bond (BTAC 2025 Edition)
The newest addition to the Antique Collection, this 15-plus year old bottled-in-bond bourbon honors the old-school standards with flavors of butterscotch, oak, and subtle fruit. It's got that classic Kentucky profile – sweet corn, vanilla, and spice – all wrapped in a smooth, full-bodied pour that's tough to beat.
Pappy Van Winkle 20 Year Old
A step down in age from the 23 but still packed with maturity, this wheated bourbon offers lush caramel, honey, and orchard fruit with refined oak tannins. The balance is spot on, delivering a velvety texture and long finish that makes it feel luxurious without overwhelming heat.
Blanton's Single Barrel
The original single barrel bourbon, each dump varies a bit, but you can expect notes of citrus, vanilla, and caramel corn with a spicy rye kick. It's collectible thanks to those horse stoppers, and the smooth, approachable style makes it a go-to for special pours.
Old Forester Birthday Bourbon
An annual limited release that changes each year, but it always brings rich toffee, baking spice, and dark fruit from well-aged barrels. The depth and warmth make it feel like a celebration in a glass, especially if you snag one from a standout vintage.
King of Kentucky Single Barrel
This high-proof, extra-aged single barrel from Brown-Forman hits with intense oak, leather, and dried cherry, balanced by sweet vanilla and spice. At 15 years or more, it's bold and layered, perfect for slow sipping on a quiet evening.
Weller Millennium
A super-limited wheated release blending old stocks, it packs orchard fruit, honey, and subtle spice with incredible smoothness from the extended aging. The rarity and pedigree make it a true collector's piece that's smooth as silk.
Four Roses Limited Edition Small Batch
Blending select recipes and ages, this annual drop often features floral notes, ripe fruit, and gentle spice with a creamy texture. It's elegant and complex, showing off why Four Roses is a master at blending.
Michter's 20 Year Old
Extremely limited and highly aged, this one bursts with deep caramel, dark chocolate, and toasted nut flavors alongside mature oak. The concentration and balance from all those years in the barrel make it a standout sipper that's worth the hunt if it ever crosses your path.
More Galleries