Bartenders Reveal Top Craft Whiskeys
Bartenders Reveal Top Craft Whiskeys
Hey fellas, if you’re the kinda guy who appreciates a solid pour after a long day, you’re gonna love this. I’ve been hitting up bartenders from dive bars to fancy joints across the country, asking what craft whiskeys they actually reach for when they’re off the clock. These ain’t the big corporate bottles you see everywhere – these are the small-batch gems that make ‘em grin. Back in my younger days I thought Jack and Coke was peak sophistication (don’t judge me), but one night this grizzled bartender in Nashville poured me something that legit changed my life. Ever since, I’ve been chasing that same “holy crap” moment. Here’s what the pros swear by in 2025.
High West Double Rye
This Utah bad boy is what happens when rye gets a PhD in flavor. Bartenders go nuts for it because it’s spicy enough to stand up in any cocktail but smooth enough to sip neat while you’re watching the game. You get that peppery kick up front, then cinnamon and vanilla roll in like your buddy who always brings the good snacks. At around 92 proof it’s got enough backbone to remind you you’re drinking whiskey, not juice. Perfect for an old fashioned that’ll make your father-in-law shut up and just enjoy the drink for once.
Widow Jane 10 Year Bourbon
Straight outta Brooklyn, this one’s aged with that fancy mineral water from the Rosendale mines. The nose hits you with butterscotch and oak, then bam – cherry and orange peel on the palate. Bartenders love throwing it in a Manhattan because it plays nice with vermouth without disappearing.
Balcones Texas Single Malt
Everything’s bigger in Texas, including the balls on this whisky. Made from 100% malted barley in Waco, it tastes like someone set a campfire in your glass – smoked brisket vibes, dark chocolate, and this leathery thing that makes you feel like a cowboy even if you’re just in Ohio wearing Carhartt.
Woodinville Straight Bourbon
Washington state don’t mess around. These guys age this full 100% in big 53-gallon barrels like the old timers, and it shows. Deep caramel, toasted marshmallow, and that baking-spice rack your wife keeps buying but never uses. Bartenders say it’s the one they reach for when a regular wants “something that tastes like bourbon used to taste” – no shortcuts, no bullshit.
Blue Run High Rye Bourbon
Kentucky finally let some new kids play, and Blue Run is running circles around the old guard. The high rye gives it this cinnamon-red-hot pop that wakes your mouth up, then waves of butterscotch and oak come calm everything down. At 13-ish years old on some batches it drinks way above its age. Bartenders pour it for the guy who swears he only drinks Pappy but can’t tell the difference when his eyes are closed.
J. Rieger Monogram Whiskey
Kansas City coming in hot with their comeback story. This is a blend of old straight whiskeys plus a kiss of Oloroso sherry, and somehow it tastes like your grandpa’s bourbon grew up, got a haircut, and started listening to jazz. Dark fruit, pipe tobacco, and a long finish that makes you lean back in the recliner and go “well I’ll be damned.” Perfect for when you wanna look classy without trying too hard.
Blue Note Juke Joint Bourbon
Memphis in a bottle, baby. This stuff is big, unfiltered, and doesn’t apologize for it. 100+ proof but drinks smoother than half the 90-proof stuff on the shelf. You get peanut brittle, banana bread, and this fat vanilla note that sticks around like a good dog. Bartenders love it ‘cause it shuts up the “higher proof is always better” crowd real quick – yeah it’s strong, but it’s strong and tasty.
Kings County Peated Bourbon
Brooklyn again, but this one’s for guys who love Islay scotch on the down-low. Sweet corn up front, then that smoky punch that lingers like your ex’s perfume. Perfect for sipping while pretending you’re rugged.
Stranahan’s Colorado Whiskey
Rocky Mountain water doing the Lord’s work. Malty, vanilla, caramel, crisp finish – like if craft beer guys made whiskey and actually nailed it.
Westward American Single Malt
Portland represent. Toasted barley gives it banana bread baked in an oak forest vibes. Fruity, spicy, creamy – killer on the rocks while you’re burning steaks.
Frey Ranch Straight Bourbon
Farm-to-glass from Nevada. Corn-forward with rye spice, fresh bread and toffee. The one bartenders pour when somebody asks for “something good but not too expensive.”
More Galleries