The Beer Bucket List: How Many for You?

The Beer Bucket List: How Many for You?

In a thorough comparison of 28 affordable beers conducted by Taste Of Home, various popular mass-market brands were put to the test to determine the top choice. The evaluation aimed to identify the most satisfying option for stocking coolers or enjoying at local watering holes. Each beer was assessed based on factors such as taste, drinkability, flavor profile, and overall value. The comprehensive analysis provided valuable insights into the diverse range of cheap beer options available, helping consumers make informed decisions when selecting their preferred brews.

28. Rolling Rock

Rolling Rock, brewed by the Latrobe Brewing Company, carries a rich history dating back to 1939, when it was first produced in Pennsylvania after the repeal of Prohibition. Over the years, the brand has changed hands multiple times, and the beer itself has undergone reformulations, with the most recent update in 2016. Despite its storied past, some testers have noted that Rolling Rock doesn't quite live up to nostalgic memories. With its light American lager profile, there's hope for a potential revival that recaptures the refreshing essence of its earlier days.

27. Natural Light

Natural Light, brewed by Anheuser-Busch, made its debut in 1977 as a light and easy-drinking beer option. True to its name, testers noted its notably light body and flavor profile. While some may appreciate its ultra-light taste and wide availability, others may find it lacking in depth compared to other brews.

26. Milwaukee’s Best Light

Milwaukee's Best Light, crafted by MillerCoors, is frequently promoted as a budget-friendly beer option. While it does offer affordability, with a 30-pack often priced below $15, testers noted its lack of flavor compared to other brews. Recognized for its extremely light profile, it may appeal to those seeking a straightforward and inexpensive beer choice.

25. Busch Light

Busch Light, crafted by Anheuser-Busch, presented a challenge for testers during evaluation. While the taste was deemed acceptable for a light beer, its distinctive aroma posed a quandary for many. Despite delivering a decent drinking experience, the peculiar scent left testers grappling to reconcile it with the beer's otherwise average flavor profile.

24. Grain Belt

Despite its reputation as the "Friendly Beer" from Minnesota, Grain Belt from August Schell Brewing Co. fell short of expectations for our testers. Described as grainy and overly sweet, it failed to impress, despite its strong fan base across the Midwest, akin to a beloved hotdish.

23. Milwaukee’s Best Ice

Milwaukee’s Best Ice from MillerCoors earned favor over its light counterpart among our testers. While refreshing when served ice cold, it fell short in flavor compared to expectations for a light beer, appearing somewhat mild. However, with a hefty 5.9 percent ABV, it certainly delivers a potent kick.

22. Bud Light

Bud Light, brewed by Anheuser-Busch, found itself in the middle of the pack in our light beer test. Although still light, it offered a somewhat more substantial and filling experience compared to its direct competitors. This characteristic may appeal to individuals seeking a light beer that doesn't feel diminished. For a delightful pairing, consider enjoying it with one of these comforting beer cheese recipes.

21. Keystone Light

Keystone Light, crafted by MillerCoors, lives up to the expectation of offering a mild flavor characteristic of light beers. Testers found its taste to be exceedingly gentle, almost airy, without being overly foamy. It serves as a decent option when you're in the mood for a light beer or seeking to concoct one of the many flavorful cocktails that begin with beer.

20. Busch

Brewed by Anheuser-Busch, Busch is characterized by its inoffensive nature. While it lacks a bold flavor profile that might excite beer enthusiasts, its mild taste makes it well-suited for casual drinking. Testers appreciated the level of carbonation present in this beer, adding to its overall appeal.

19. Yuengling

Brewed by D.G. Yuengling & Son, Inc., Yuengling stands out as the sole amber lager in this test, drawing attention for its departure from the typical mass-market beers. Testers noted its darker hue, fuller body, and hints of molasses in the flavor profile. While not necessarily a top choice for summer, it offers comfort and warmth on cooler days.

18. Red Dog

Brewed by MillerCoors, Red Dog pleasantly surprised testers who initially had low expectations. While primarily characterized by corn and grain flavors typical of budget-friendly beers, it offered a smooth and enjoyable drinking experience. Despite its reputation among college students, testers found it worthy of consideration for future enjoyment.

17. Natural Ice

Brewed by Anheuser-Busch, Natural Ice pleasantly surprised testers with its smoothness and subtle sweetness, distinguishing it from its lighter counterpart, Natty Light. With a high alcohol by volume (ABV) of 5.9 percent, it provided a stronger kick for those seeking a bit more potency in their brew.

16. Budweiser

Brewed by Anheuser-Busch, Budweiser is a reliable choice for those seeking a straightforward and easy-drinking beer. With a light and slightly biscuity flavor profile, it's perfect for quenching your thirst after outdoor activities like mowing the lawn. Its uncomplicated nature makes it ideal for pairing with beer bread recipes.

15. Lone Star

Brewed by the Pabst Brewing Company, Lone Star, hailing from Texas, may not live up to its larger-than-life reputation but still offers a pleasant experience. This American lager presents a subdued profile with grainy notes and a hint of citrus, making it a suitable companion for barbecue or Texas-inspired recipes.

14. Miller Genuine Draft

Brewed by MillerCoors, Miller Genuine Draft earns its reputation as a solid middle-of-the-road beer. With a smooth profile devoid of extremes—neither overly hoppy nor too malty, bitter, or sweet—it's a crowd-pleaser ideal for outdoor gatherings and tailgates. Pair it with cheesy, spicy, or salty game day snacks for the perfect complement.

13. Leinenkugel’s Original Ale

Brewed by Jacob Leinenkugel Brewing Company, Leinenkugel’s Original presents a satisfying lager experience with wheat notes and a hint of hoppy bitterness on the finish. Despite its relative complexity for a mass-market beer, it didn't stand out enough in testing to become our top pick from the cooler.

12. Michelob Ultra

Brewed by Anheuser-Busch, Michelob Ultra proved to be a refreshing and thirst-quenching beer with a light body that goes down easily. Its mild flavor profile features faint malty notes, making it a suitable choice for those seeking a low-carb beer, with only 2.6 grams of carbs per 12-ounce bottle. However, it may not satisfy those looking for a more robust beer flavor to savor.

11. Miller High Life

Brewed by MillerCoors, Miller High Life is often dubbed the "Champagne of Beers," and while we may not fully agree with that claim, it does offer a satisfying malty brew with a hint of bitter hops. This beer boasts a higher level of carbonation compared to others, lending some credence to its champagne moniker. While it may not cater to those preferring milder flavors, Miller High Life provides a refreshing option with its unique characteristics.

10. Blatz

Brewed by the Pabst Brewing Company, Blatz may evoke memories of yesteryears, but its flavor profile surprises with a malty sweetness and a fuller body, finishing cleanly and leaving a desire for another sip. While it may not appeal to occasional beer drinkers, Blatz earns its place in the fridge, particularly for game day gatherings.

9. Old Style

Brewed by the Pabst Brewing Company, Old Style stands as a Midwest staple, originating in Wisconsin in 1902 and gaining favor among Cubs fans. With its rich yet light flavor, Old Style offers a pleasant, mild bread-like taste that makes for a smooth and enjoyable sip, explaining its enduring popularity over the years.

8. Miller Lite

Brewed by MillerCoors, Miller Lite is lauded by testers as a classic "boat beer" with its light body, subtle citrus notes, and refreshing taste, making it an ideal choice for a day spent on the water. Its versatility extends to being a convenient option for last-minute gatherings or outdoor excursions, earning it a spot as a go-to brew for various occasions.

7. Old Milwaukee

Brewed by Pabst Brewing Company, Old Milwaukee stands out with its slightly malty and creamy profile, setting it apart from the lighter corn-flavored beers on the list. Despite its vintage-sounding name, Old Milwaukee proves to be a worthy contemporary choice, earning praise from testers for its pleasant aroma, taste, and overall quality.

6. Icehouse

Brewed by MillerCoors, Icehouse surprised beer enthusiasts by claiming a top spot. Despite its budget-friendly price point, Icehouse impressed with its crisp and smooth taste, devoid of any off-putting flavors often associated with cheaper beer options. Ideal for gatherings and outdoor events, Icehouse offers a satisfying brew that you can enjoy all day long without breaking the bank.

5. Coors Light

Brewed by MillerCoors, Coors Light earns its reputation as the quintessential summer beer with its crisp and refreshing taste, making it a favorite among testers. With its mild corn flavor and subtle sweetness, Coors Light strikes a perfect balance, offering an uncomplicated yet satisfying drinking experience. As a top pick for light beer, it's an ideal choice for warm weather and outdoor occasions.

4. Hamm’s

Brewed by MillerCoors, Hamm's offers a satisfying and straightforward beer experience, perfect for those seeking an unpretentious option. With its clean taste, mild sweetness, and subtle maltiness, Hamm's captures the essence of its Minnesota roots. Surprisingly affordable, this beer delivers great flavor and a clean finish, making it a compelling choice for any cooler lineup.

3. Schlitz

Brewed by the Pabst Brewing Company, Schlitz offers a departure from the lighter, milder beers typically found in this category. This American lager presents a bolder and more flavorful profile without weighing heavy on the palate. With distinctive citrusy notes and hints of green hops, Schlitz stands out as a more complex option among mass-market beers, appealing to those seeking a bit more depth in their brew.

2. Coors Banquet

Brewed by MillerCoors, Coors Banquet has a storied history dating back to 1873 when it was first brewed in Golden, Colorado—a tradition that continues to this day. Originally dubbed "Banquet Beer" by locals who relished its flavor, it was officially christened Coors Banquet in 1937. With its rich heritage and consistently satisfying taste, Coors Banquet has earned its place as one of the top choices among mass-market beers.

1. Pabst Blue Ribbon (PBR)

Pabst Blue Ribbon (PBR), brewed by Pabst Brewing Company, has a legacy dating back to 1893 when it was honored as America's finest beer. Today, it continues to impress as a favorite affordable option, earning its iconic blue ribbon. PBR stood out in our test for its affordability at $9 for a 12-pack and its universally pleasing taste. Testers found it smooth, refreshing, and clean, with a balanced flavor profile featuring notes of grains, biscuits, sweetness, and maltiness complemented by a hint of bitterness from the hops. PBR emerged as the standard bearer, topping our score sheets and solidifying its status as a classic choice.